Switch language

Menu

Fines are too high for people affected by poverty: Here’s what we can do about it

Justice Collective

Image featuring penalty orders (Strafbefehle) and coins to illustrate fines.

For several years, Justice Collective has been monitoring criminal proceedings in Berlin to document and challenge systemic injustices in the punishment system. Together with the Society for Civil Rights (Gesellschaft für Freiheitsrechte, GFF), we are now launching a new project to bring about lasting changes to judicial practices that result in excessive fines being imposed on people living at or below the subsistence level. We see this initiative as part of a broader effort to build a society that addresses the root causes of social inequality rather than punishing people for its consequences.

Every year, hundreds of thousands of people in Germany face criminal prosecution and sanctions. As our court monitoring and research have shown, state surveillance, prosecution, and punishment disproportionately target people affected by poverty, racism, and other intersecting forms of marginalization – often for minor offenses such as shoplifting or fare evasion.

Fines are the most common form of criminal sanction in Germany. They can have serious consequences for those affected, particularly people already living at or below the subsistence level or people with precarious immigration status. Many are unable to pay their fines and end up in prison as a result, due to the so-called Ersatzfreiheitsstrafe.

One reason for this is that criminal courts frequently set daily fine rates at levels that are way too high. Although a 2023 legislative reform requires that people convicted of an offense must be left with at least the minimum income necessary to meet their basic needs when fines are calculated, our courtwatching shows that this requirement is rarely reflected in judicial practice. As a result, many people continue to receive fines that put their livelihoods at risk.

At Justice Collective, we are challenging these practices in several ways. Together with the Disrupt Mass Criminalization coalition, we regularly attend proceedings at Berlin’s fast-track court (Schnellgericht) to provide solidarity-based support to people affected by criminalization. This includes legal advice and representation, assistance with filling out applications, and help with paying off fines.

We are now launching a new project together with the Society for Civil Rights (GFF) to bring about lasting changes to the judicial practices that result in excessive fines being imposed on people affected by poverty.

Our joint project takes a two-pronged approach:

1. A template for challenging excessive fines

We have created a template that people can use to appeal a penal order (Strafbefehl) and challenge an excessive fine themselves. The template, along with instructions on how to use it, is available for download here.

2. Strategic litigation to establish clear legal standards

Through strategic litigation in four to five suitable cases, we aim to secure rulings by higher regional courts that establish clear standards for calculating daily fine rates. Such a ruling could make a difference for many people, far beyond the individual cases involved. The GFF has put together an FAQ explaining this approach, which is available here.

We particularly encourage criminal defense lawyers and counseling services to get in touch if they know of potentially suitable cases. Please send any information to tagessatz [at] freiheitsrechte.org. The FAQs also provide guidance on which cases are particularly suitable.

In addition, we will also offer two free online events for criminal defense lawyers and social workers who may want to know more about the project and get involved.

1. Online briefing for criminal defense lawyers

December 8, 5:00–6:00 pm | Online

In cooperation with the Republikanischer Anwältinnen- und Anwälteverein, RAV

With Lukas Theune, Valentina Chiofalo, and Anthony Obst

2. Webinar for professionals in social counseling and other interested participants

January 25, 10:00–11:30 am | Online

In cooperation with the Bundesarbeitsgemeinschaft für Straffälligenhilfe, BAG-S

With Nicole Bögelein, Valentina Chiofalo, and Lara Möller

To register for either event, please email info [at] justice-collective.org by the day before the respective event.

The project “Gegen Armutsbestrafung – Rechtshilfe am Schnellgericht” is funded by the Mercator Foundation.

Cases from our archive

Case 39

A young woman experiencing homelessness is sentenced to 90 days of fine payment for supplying drugs. The conviction will not appear on her Certificate of Good Conduct (Führungszeugnis), which was important to her, but the court punishes her with a high fine even as it acknowledges she was supplying drugs because of her poverty.

The War on Drugs
Racist Policing
Criminalizing Poverty
Fine
Drug Offense

Case 34

A man faces trial for stealing a small quantity of food and alcohol. In cases involving substance use (including alcohol and other drugs), courts often want to hear that people facing trial have stopped using substances, are working, or otherwise trying to fit into society. While the defendant ticks all these boxes, and the judge seemingly acknowledges punishment will be counterproductive, she sentences him to a high fine anyway, ending by saying, “Those are the consequences of committing a crime. You should have thought of that at the time.”

Criminalizing Poverty
The War on Drugs
Fine
Theft

Case 32

After spending three nights in pretrial detention, a man faces accelerated proceedings on theft charges for stealing goods valued at about €50. He is sentenced to seven months prison as the prosecutor and judge see his repeated theft offenses as evidence not of his life challenges but rather the need for a harsh sentence. Joined by the person’s attorney, all seem to believe the best place for treatment is in prison.

Criminalizing Poverty
The War on Drugs
Prison
Theft

Case 31

A young man who was unhoused and jailed pretrial is sentenced to pay €750 in fines for theft of food, toiletries, and other small items. Although the court acknowledged that he is experiencing problems related to drug use and poverty, the judge finds that the defendant should have simply “said no” to drugs. The sentence came with a warning that any future offense would lead to incarceration.

Criminalizing Poverty
The War on Drugs
Fine
Theft

Perspectives